Saturday, February 23, 2013

Kotoura-san - 07

shot0010 shot0028 shot0040

Among the many things I like about Kotoura-san, I have to give it full credit for this one - it continues to surprise me.

As I mentioned last week, the thing I was really worried about in this edition of Kotoura-san is what was going to happen with Kumiko (Haruka's mother).  Given some of the concerns I had about the rushed nature of Moritani and Mifune's redemption (which Moritani's continued humble status in the social hierarchy of the cast have somewhat allayed in her case) Kuriko's situation seemed rife with danger.  But much to my surprise, it ended up playing a very small role in the episode itself - an episode which, like #6, seems to indicate that the show has found a nice middle ground between comedy and drama.

As it turned out, Kumiko's presence was entirely due to the well-meaning Osho-san, not some mission of vengeance on her part.  On balance you'd have to give Kotoura-san an "Incomplete" here because the series really didn't address the conflict, merely deferred it.  But on balance I think what they did address they did rather well.  Kumiko is clearly not feeling especially loving towards the daughter she abandoned, but there are signs that she's at least troubled by what's happened - and for now at least, smart enough to realize that by intruding on Haruka's happiness she's likely to do little but ruin it.

Of course, Osho's plan could hardly be kept from Haruka-chan, and she knew as soon as got close enough to the priest to read his thoughts that her mother had been watching her.  I thought her reaction was pretty spot-on as well - wistful yes, but not overwrought (which constitutes some growth for her character).  The fact is that Kotoura is such a forgiving person by nature that it won't take much more than a sense of regret from Kumiko for her daughter to forgive her, and I'm looking at that possibility with a certain amount of trepidation even still.  But it's nevertheless nice to see Haruka not consumed with anger or fear of abandonment that she can't appreciate the fact that things have gotten a whole lot better in her life.  There's still some bad places where this thread could lead, but for now so far, so good.

As for the rest of the episode, it amounted to some very well-executed comedy and character development.  For the first time the series adopted a "mini-episode" format, which might not be an unusual occurrence given the track record of Ohta-sensei when dealing with 4-koma manga.  The first of these dealt with the remainder of the ESP Club's retreat at Grandpa's estate, where he and Manabe strike oil when trying to dig up an onsen so that they might have a mixed bath with Kotoura (the rich make money without even trying to - such is life).  The highlight of this chapter is no doubt Mori's cooking - which is apparently not only vile but highly hallucinogenic as well.  This leads to a rather hilarious sequence in which she more or less tries to rape Manabe and he tries to get to second-base with a Kotoura-sized vase (much of this imagined, of course) before the three of them wake up together, only Kotoura wearing clothes.  Mori's interpretation of Kotoura's innocent "You two were really going at it" remark leads to the best single comic moment of the episode, Oedipus Rex style.

Back in Tokyo, Manabe is keeping secrets from Haruka - a fairly big deal, as his transparency was really at the heart of his character and relationship with Haruka.  My first thought when seeing that he was constantly doing multiplication tables in his head when around her was that he was trying to block out his ecchi thoughts but no, he had a deeper reason.  Meanwhile Haruka turns to Mifune for advice, which leads to a flashback that does a very nice job illuminating her past with Muroto-kun a little (there's fair potential in that relationship I think - it's refreshingly different from the usual osananajimi dynamic).  Manabe's real reason, meanwhile, in blocking Haruka out is that he's been working (wearing a bear suit) to earn enough to plan a surprise party for Haruka-chan's birthday.  And of course he couldn't tell anyone, because then their thoughts would be subject to piracy by her - and as he admits himself, he likes to show off once in a while.

I rather liked that last sequence.  It was played mostly for laughs, but there was a nice amount of subtle meaning there too.  If Kotoura and Manabe are going to enter into a real relationship - and I certainly hope they are - isn't he entitled to a certain amount of privacy?  How, exactly, would a romantic relationship with her work?  For all his honesty and lack of deceit or pretense, he's still a human and a teenaged guy at that - there are going to be moments when he doesn't want her rummaging about in his brain.  It's a gentle reminder, I think, that there are very real challenges still facing Kotoura as a result of her unique nature.  I'm not sure we're going to see that explored in any real depth in a one-cour season, but if the series gets another go-around - and pre-sales look pretty good - we just might.

shot0008 shot0011 shot0012
shot0013 shot0014 shot0015
shot0016 shot0018 shot0019
shot0021 shot0023 shot0024
shot0025 shot0026 shot0031
shot0032 shot0033 shot0034
shot0035 shot0037 shot0039
shot0042 shot0043 shot0044

ED4:
shot0045 shot0047 shot0048


4 comments:

  1. At least one of the shows I like is selling well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm sure we have NOT seen the end of her mom.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The less I comment about mommy dearest the better. But given the premise and how... compressed the parental abuse&abandonment related parts have been so far I'm sorta glad there was very little on-screen presence this week and that the most poignant and adquately presented drama moment feautred the disgraceful genitrix only in a oblique way via her room.
    ---
    And now, delicious comedic parts!
    I was just in the mood for some fellowship of the spring. And fellowsheet as well. *bricked* Hilariously enough Moritani is quite the caveman and Manabe seemigly switches between defenseless maiden/uke and tireless pottery groper when under psychotropic food XD. I can quite get that part of his behaviour truth to be told. Ahhhh, the pleasures of fine ceramics <3.
    ---
    Also, Muroto-kun was such a cuuuute&supportive sensible shota. Sans glasses he probably still looks the same too XD. It's funny really. His pseudo-chibi teen appereance reminds me a lot of this old anime** http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=anime&aid=1822( personality-wise the protag if anything is closer to Manabe instead. Horny and in love ).
    While Manabe seems to be able to shield his thoughts quite aptly and for long periods of time I think Kotoura too needs to build a pair of mental earplugs and put them to use to allow both other people and herself a break and some peace of mind. Her circumstances are finally favourable now to start working a bit on this I think. Well, mommy notwithstanding.



    **talking of old anime refs, in the previous episodes Kotoura's training sequence and the metal springs contraption she was forced to wear was a callback to training from hell in volleyball series of my childhood. Either Attacker You! or Attack Number One (this one had also chain wearing to strengthen the wrists. While receiving balls. Suffering and sweat and bleeding ensued. Ok, this sounds a bit equivocal).
    In any case it really added an extra layer of LOL to Kotoura for me.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really hope they don't go down this mother subplot path. Given how the Moritani situation was handled it can only end with me raging at what should have been a fairly competent show. The Moritani thing means this show is already skating on thin ice for me, any more strikes and they'll be out (mixed metaphors woo!).

    ReplyDelete