Sunday, March 17, 2013

First Impressions - RDG: Red Data Girl

RDG - 1-2 RDG - 1-25 RDG - 1-26

The calendar says it's winter for another 4 days, but as far as anime is concerned this is the first day of spring.


OP: "Small worldrop (スモルワールドロップ)" by Annabel
RDG - 1-4 RDG - 1-5 RDG - 1-6
RDG - 1-7 RDG - 1-8 RDG - 1-9


The new season kicks off with a special preview of one of the more hotly anticipated shows of Spring, Red Data Girl from P.A. Works.  As always with Niconico I apologize for the poor quality of the images, but even so, it's clear to see the usual P.A. Works art style carries the day.  It's hard to describe just what I find so appealing about their look - I suppose it has a sort of romantic quality to it, an "art for art's sake" sensibility that strives for beauty over accuracy.  Character designs are by Shiba Minako (off templates from HanaIro designer Kishida Mel), yet another longtime industry veteran in a staff full of them.

In terms of story, there are definitely some growing pains in the premiere, but I see the bone structure of a very interesting premise showing through.  Even by first episode standards this one had a huge amount of exposition to get out of the way, and the flow of the episode suffered a bit as a result.  The first-flush impressions of the characters are a bit standard as well, certainly nothing we haven't seen before.  My suspicion is that this is a mostly a first-episode issue, but not having read the novel I have to take that on faith.  Unlike LNs - most of which seem written with possible anime adaptations in mind - novels don't necessarily lend themselves to seamless transitions in premieres.  The premise is pretty grabby right from the start though, for me at least.

My initial take on RDG was that it was going to be wholly Shinto-based, and middle-school heroine Suzuhara Izumiko (Hayami Saori) is indeed a Miko.  But she's actually at one of the Kumano Shrines, which are deeply rooted in practices even older and are really more historically associated with Shugendou, an ancient religion of mountain worship that combines elements of Shinto, Taosim and especially esoteric Buddhism.  That comes into play well into the episode with the introduction of Sagara Yukimasa (Fukuyama Jun), the man standing in as Izumiko's guardian while her father is in America and her mother is apparently wandering Japan permanently.  Sagara is a Yamabushi, one of the mountain ascetics who practice the Shugendou faith - though he little resembles the stereotypical image.

We meet a number of other characters in this very busy first episode: Izumiko's father Daisei (the great Inoue Kazuhiko), several schoolmates including kind but slightly creepy Wamiya Satoru (Rie Kugimiya, who really should stick to girls, prepubescent boys and cute animals) and most importantly Sagara Miyuki (Kouki Uchiyama).  He's apparently Yukimasa's son despite referring to him by his given name, and his fate in life is to be the servant (and I'm assuming guardian-protector) of Izumiko.  It's strongly implied that Izumiko is a Goddess (in Shugendou all mountain Kami are female, which is why women have historically been forbidden from holy mountains - they make the Kami jealous).  Izumiko has the interesting trait of causing any electronics she touches to go haywire (although this seems not to apply to helicopters) which means she can't use computers or cell phones.  Naturally this makes her a bit of an outcast from middle-school society, though there are clearly girls in her rural school sympathetic to her plight.

Izumiko and Miyuki are clearly going to be the focus of the story, and it's going to take some time for them to break out of their somewhat cliche “beauty and the beast” roles, I suspect.  She's a classic shy megane-girl, someone who wants to fit in but can't do what everyone else does.  He's a sort of iconic bad boy, an angry and sullen brat who clearly disdains Yukimasa's "anachronistic" belief system.  Izumiko's father wants her to attend high school in Tokyo (reasons not stated) but she wants to stay local, so Yukimasa makes the executive decision to force Miyuki to transfer in rather than have them attend school together in the city (he's none too thrilled).  However, given the synopses, it seems clear that the two of them at least are going to end up in Tokyo anyway sooner or later (which will make me sad if it deprives us of P.A. Works' legendary bucolic scenery porn, very much on display in the premiere).

I can see where not everyone will be overly impressed by this episode - I wasn't blown away myself - but as I said, I see the makings of something quite interesting underneath.  In addition to the lovely visuals I like both the OP and ED from two terrific singers, Annabel and Masumi Itou (Ito’s ED song is especially winning).  There's clearly a willingness to go dark, as witness Yukimasa beating up Miyuki to compel him to play along with his plan (using the classic child abuser excuse "He fell down").  With the introductions out of the way I expect the premise to really take off, though I do worry that it seems to have too much scope for a one-cour adaptation.  What will really tell the tale is whether the two leads emerge as interesting and original creations or stay safely inside well-defined cliches - I think that's what will determine whether Red Data Girl is a good series (the plot alone is enough to carry it that far, I'm guessing) or an exceptional one.

RDG - 1-14 RDG - 1-15 RDG - 1-16
RDG - 1-17 RDG - 1-18 RDG - 1-19
RDG - 1-20 RDG - 1-21 RDG - 1-22
RDG - 1-23 RDG - 1-24 RDG - 1-27
RDG - 1-28 RDG - 1-29 RDG - 1-30


ED: "Yokan (予感)" by Masumi Itou
RDG - 1-31 RDG - 1-32 RDG - 1-33


15 comments:

  1. If anything, it felt like I was watching the prelude to a reverse-harem more than anything else. That and all the characters (the male ones mainly) just seem plain insipid.

    Like I stated in my other comment (in your Spring 2013 Preview), I'll give it a couple more eps.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't see this going down that reverse-harem road, but who knows.

      Delete
  2. Am I the only one that hates this studio's animation?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, I don't care much for it either. Digitally painted pastoral scenery never really does it for me.

      "What will really tell the tale is whether the two leads emerge as interesting and original creations or stay safely inside well-defined cliches - I think that's what will determine whether Red Data Girl is a good series (the plot alone is enough to carry it that far, I'm guessing) or an exceptional one."
      Isn't that always the case though?

      Delete
    2. I can think of way more series where the plot wasn't interesting enough to carry it to "good" than ones where it was.

      Delete
    3. Sorry, no. At least 70% of the anime I try to watch.

      Delete
    4. So from that 30% What were some of those that met the sufficient plot criteria to carry them through?

      Delete
  3. That was fast! ^^ Anyway, I somehow agree that the first episode gave me that vibe--the reverse harem vibe. However, as Enzo had stated about the Kami being jealous...maybe it's like that? Hmm...

    The ep wasn't very mind-blowing and all that, but I guess it established the kind of relationships that characters will have and need some work on. I am somehow more interested in the kind of development the characters will undergo that makes the source novel award-winning...

    I do wonder though until what volume they will adapt...because it seems like the source is a series of ongoing fantasy novels...unlike Shinsekai Yori...

    I've seen the PV of this and some teaser pics, so it seems to have some action and a little horror later on. But Idk...yet.=.=

    It's been a long time, Enzo! Although you might not remember me. ^^

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think the that what makes LNs (and mangas for that matter) more adaptation friendly is that unlike novels they're serials and that means that the first chapters always try and serve as a hook right away which isn't the case with novels where a first chapter could just be pure exposition.

    I liked this episode well enough , it set everything up now things just need to get moving,and they're going to have to get moving fast because there's 6 novels and only one cour, Yokote has her work cut out for her.Unless there's good cutoff point somewhere.

    ReplyDelete
  5. the first episode did its job setting up its characters and some of the hurdles they will have to overcome pretty decently. Here's hoping the next episode capitalizes on that and demonstrates why this novel series is award-winning. Im definitely liking what i see so far.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I always have mixed feelings about PA Works. There's the sense of things being beautiful but empty, yet there seems to be this sort of promise there. I remember once saying something about Canaan and True Tears where I had been trying to get this idea across, but I said something a bit different:

    http://www.lostinanime.com/2012/09/tari-tari-13-end-and-series-review.html

    ReplyDelete
  7. I wasn't blown away, but it's like Enzo said that there were a lot to tell in this first episode for setting the stage -- I will stick around, as I am curious and prone to shows that are based on novels and manga. I am hoping that I will see more of the characters -- and the dynamics amongst them -- as the story moves along.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I'm glad I waited for the HD airing to watch this, because I would have been so disappointed in the streaming quality. It really was a gorgeous premiere, like I expect from PA Works. It feels like you'd just be depriving yourself to watch it in lower quality.

    I found the story really interesting, even though I am not the biggest fan of shy girl characters. Izumiko really does seem like she wants to change from how she is, and I thought the 'little girl' looks with the pajamas and the elephant mug were an interesting look, really driving home the sheltered nature of this girl.

    Definitely looking forward to more.

    ReplyDelete
  9. listens to ED - cannot stop thinking of jinrui
    i like PA's style too, the palette is just so pink... i don't know... haha

    ReplyDelete